Tangled Web UK Review August 1998
File Updated: 31/03/00
The Bone Yard by Paul Johnston
pbk out April 99 (NEL) at £5.99
How, enquired one of the many laudatory reviews of Body Politic, his Creasey Award-winning debut, might Paul Johnston develop his 21st century sleuth Quintilian Dalrymple and his hometown, the scrupulously detailed independent city state of Edinburgh?
Not that much is the disappointing answer. True, the city has fallen on hard times. After a world catastrophe or two, revenues from one of the city's few lifelines, its rich Arab and Far Eastern tourists, have dried up. So it is no surprise that the city system, built around the principles set down for Callipolis, the utopian city of Platos Republic, and now reinforced by a newer, younger set of guardians, is looking increasingly shop-worn, not to mention sexually decadent.
The first hint of something amiss comes at a city Council New Year party when Dalrymple catches an unguarded reference to The Bone Yard. Then an old friend of his turns up dead; stuffed inside the sexually mutilated body is a tape of Eric Clapton playing the blues (Tribute to Elmore, for the cognoscenti). Naturally, as this modern utopia has largely (and mysteriously) succeeded in banishing murder, and Dalrymple is about the only citizen around with experience in detecting its perpetrators, he is asked to investigate...
Johnston just about successfully negotiates the problem that often besets the sci-fi writer: how to reconcile the creation of a credible milieu with a smooth, easily assimilated prose style. But then characterisation suffers somewhat as the writer leavens his literary landscape (and dialogue) with a clutch of often entertaining but sub-Chandler similes, spread indiscriminately amongst his cast. And no amount of classical trappings, blues references and 21st century fireworks can disguise the workings of some fairly well-worn plot devices.
But read this book as a fast-moving, often bitterly funny thriller, set in an imaginative world of a kind rarely encountered in crime fiction and you'll probably enjoy it.


( Bob Cornwell )

top