Tangled Web UK Review November 2004
File Updated: 06/11/04

Buy at Amazon Price Out Out by Natsuo Kirino
pbk out September 04 (Vintage) at £6.99

Caught out again. No sooner had I picked out Robert Wilson's The Silent and the Damned as the best I'd read this year, then along comes this one. Shortlisted for the Edgar, passed over in favour of Ian Rankin, then sadly omitted from the CWA's Gold Dagger shortlist, here's a book that anyone who prizes the best in crime fiction should read.
Masako Katori is one of four women trapped in a dead-end night shift job in a factory assembling boxed lunches for sale in Tokyo's many thousands of convenience stores. The work is poorly paid, back-breaking and regimented, the efficiency on the assembly line depending on its weakest link. Yoshie, the backbone of the line, is a widow with an invalid mother and a teenage daughter. Kuniko copes with the stress of the job and an unfeeling partner by feeding her increasing girth. Yayoi is at her wits end: while she scrapes some kind of a living on behalf of her two kids, her increasingly violent husband has frittered away their savings in the baccarat and hostess clubs of Tokyo. A display one night of his indifference to her suffering is finally too much: she strangles him with a handy belt. Led by Masako, the group rally round to conceal the murder and dispose of the body.
The steadily mounting tension of the first half of the book, of course, results from the 'will they be found out' mechanic, particularly once the police become involved, alerted when some carelessly discarded body parts are discovered. But note how the author, whilst continuing to fill out the impoverished lives of her female characters, gradually broadens her canvas to include figures from the equally deadly background of the Tokyo underworld, the loan sharks that feed on the unwary for instance, and, as police suspicions widen, key players in the night club where Yayoi's husband lost his money.
But as the book continues, its focus gradually shifts. Whilst never losing sight of the plight of the four women, Masako moves to centre stage, her strength growing as she copes with the aftermath of the murder. It's an evolution that sets in motion a series of events that lift the book onto a different level entirely and leads finally to the book's staggeringly transgressive, haunting and yes, liberating climax. It's an ending that will stay with you for days, if not weeks and months. And it's only as you ponder the outcome that you realise just how carefully you have been prepared for it. Mistaking subject for style, the book has been criticised as both drab and slow, Kirino's achievment (she has won both literary and crime fiction prizes in Japan) lies in bringing those drab lives to life and then forging something entirely distinctive and original from the material. Nor does Stephen Snyder's translation strike any false notes. It's a book that can be read on several levels: as a slow-burning thriller of unusual subtlety, as a story of l'amour fou, or as a candid analysis of lives, particularly female lives, lived at the edge of Japanese society. As for the slowness, well, it never dragged for me. About as far from the glib mechanics of Harlan Coben and the like as it is possible to get, there is always sufficient depth of theme and characterisation to keep the interest going, as well as a plot that is a marvel of construction.
A major book. Don't miss out on this one.


( Bob Cornwell )

New Books by Natsuo Kirino at Amazon.co.uk Buy at Amazon.co.uk
click here
Used Books at ABE  

top